Puny Punitives

Punitive damage awards come up only occasionally in medical malpractice cases because punitive damages are only awarded to “penalize, punish, or deter” a defendant.   Doctors are typically trying to help but make mistakes out of ignorance, fatigue, or even sloth – and are financially held to account for these kinds of mistakes when they cause injury – but rarely do doctors do something they should be punished for.  The typical situation in which punitive damages might be awarded would be a surgeon who injures a patient while performing an operation under the influence of alcohol or drugs.  But, these cases are uncommon.  Rarer still would be a doctor who deliberately harmed a patient for some crazed personal reason.  More commonly, punitive damages come up in product liability cases because it is not hard to imagine a company cutting corners when it comes to safety, in order to fatten its bottom line.  Rightly or wrongly, I’m pretty sure some business executives will do unethical things in their business life that they would never dream of doing in their personal life.

Perhaps because punitive-damage cases are infrequent, state and federal governments have acted like these cases should be their personal play things.  Georgia has taken an interesting approach, for example, by confiscating 75% of any punitive damages awarded in a product-liability case.  Other states cap punitive damages.  Even the U.S. Supreme Court has declared that “few awards exceeding a single-digit ratio between punitive and compensatory damages, to a significant degree, will satisfy due process.”  In other words, if a punitive-damages award exceeds 9 times the actual damages, it’ll probably be deemed unconstitutional.

This past week, a Richmond, Virginia federal jury awarded Douglas M. Ray, a retired engineer, $12 million in compensatory damages and $200 million in punitive damages. The jury agreed that Ray, 67, suffered disability and permanent brain damage when, in 2007, he was given Botox injections, off-label, for hand tremors; the manufacturer of Botox had not warned about this potential side effect.

Here’s the kicker: Allergan, the manufacturer of Botox, hasn’t decided whether to appeal.  Not appeal a $212 million verdict?  Has the manufacturer lost its senses?             No.  You see, the Commonwealth of Virginia caps punitive damages at $250, 000.  Thus, the verdict is really only $12.25 million and Mr. Ray’s disability could make Allergan consider that it got off easy.

Glenn L. Goodhart, M.D., J.D. 

6065 Roswell Rd.

Northside Tower
Suite 410

Sandy Springs, GA 30328

Phone: (404) 255-3282

Toll Free: 866-959-2148
Follow PubProtecLawyer on Twitter


About Public Protection Lawyer

lawyer and physician
This entry was posted in Medical Malpractice. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Puny Punitives

  1. You made some good points there. I did a search on the field and found the majority of persons will have the same idea with your blog. Thanks! quite helpful post.

  2. Facts are detailed, I’ve been looking for this kind of post since my mom encountered some issues with her medicare together with malpractice issues. I’ve been reading all over the net and this the first I found a very relevant post. Thanks for you help!

  3. Lulaine says:

    Punitive damages should only be used when the court is trying to send a message to the defendant and other people who may commit the same crime, like a Ponzi scheme. They are probably the most expensive damages the court can award thus they have to be used carefully. Most of the time companies would appeal, but I agree that the company thought it was wise to let it be with knowledge of the caps. Had the argued the punitive damages another court might have awarded something lower but way more expensive than what they have to pay now.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s