The autism blowup at The Lancet

Earlier this week, The Lancet, the prestigious British medical journal, published the following short retraction:

It doesn’t get any more serious in the world of science.  Ordinarily,  a scientist who realizes an error in one of his published papers simply stops referring to the report and allows it to die an unceremonious death.    Occasionally, a scientist of especial probity will voluntarily publish a retraction and explanation.  But, it is distinctly unusual for someone to be accused of scientific fraud, much less twelve years later.    What usually follows is a series of denials and recriminations, finger pointing and objurgation, though mostly in-house, because science usually affects only scientists.  The big controversies that spill over to the general public–and this one is the biggest in years–typically leads to great fonts of oratory from people who don’t know much about science,  but who do hold the reins of power.  Heaven forfend, we will not see any of our wise Solons in Washington pass new laws or regulations to protect us from future trespasses.

Of course, we treat autistic kids at Atlanta Hyperbaric.  And, they are very dear to me.  As I’ve said many times before, I would love to have a practice that ONLY treats children, for the selfish reason that it makes me feel good to help out kids who will be around long after I’m gone.  Consequently, this English dust up hits pretty close to home.

Few minds will be changed by The Lancet retraction.  Even though mainstream medicine subsequently brought forward a large volume of research casting doubt on any association between vaccines containing mercury preservatives and autism, The Lancet report did much to propel the controversy.  People took sides and, depending on their view of the dispute, kids paid the price either by going unvaccinated and risking mumps, measles and rubella or by getting vaccinated and risking autism.   The great gods of government stepped in and took Thimerosal, the main mercury-based preservative in the United States, off the market.   Litigation has raged, including a recent plaintiffs’ decision by the Georgia Supreme Court. [American Home Products v. Ferrari, 284 Ga. 384, 668 S.E.2d 236 (2008.)]  I suspect that hundreds of millions (more?) of dollars have been spent on this controversy.

What can we learn from this mess?  We already knew that scientists were human and subject to the same character flaws as everyone else.  We also knew what side the weight of scientific evidence fell in this particular instance.  So I guess we really don’t learn anything.  More scandals will occur, more pundits will opine, more people will be injured and more money wasted.  And, God help us, more politicians will solve our problems.


About Public Protection Lawyer

lawyer and physician
This entry was posted in autism, Hyperbaric Medicine. Bookmark the permalink.

22 Responses to The autism blowup at The Lancet

  1. Liz Ditz says:

    I sometimes write a post that collates blog responses, both positive and negative, to a given issue.

    I’m keeping one now on responses to the Lancet retraction of the Wakefield’s paper.

    I’ve added your post to the list.

    The post is at

  2. Anonymous says:

    Thimerosal has not been taken off the market. It is still used in vaccine manufacturer. Most injected influenza vaccinations still contain 25 micrograms of ethylmercury from Thimerosal, or 50,000 parts per billion. The EPA limit for potable water (ingested) is 4 parts per billion. This information is available on FDA and CDC websites.

    A study from Washington State by Burbacher et al showed that ethylmercury lodged in the brains of macaque primates given Thimerosal at a rate of 2-4 times more than methylmercury, which is ingested from fish consumption. A UC-Davis study showed that Thimerosal damages and kills dendrites and interfers with calcium channels, thus damaging immune function, at 20-40 ppb.

    Dr. Andrew Wakefield’s MMR research has been replicated in other studies:

    Gonzalez, L. et al., “Endoscopic and Histological Characteristics of the Digestive Mucosa in Autistic Children with gastro-Intestinal Symptoms”. Arch Venez Pueric Pediatr, 2005;69:19-25.

    Balzola, F., et al., “Panenteric IBD-like disease in a patient with regressive autism shown for the first time by wireless capsule enteroscopy: Another piece in the jig-saw of the gut-brain syndrome?” American Journal of Gastroenterology, 2005. 100(4): p. 979- 981.

    S. Walker, K. Hepner, J. Segal, A. Krigsman “Persistent Ileal Measles Virus in a Large Cohort of Regressive Autistic Children with Ileocolitis and Lymphonodular Hyperplasia: Revisitation of an Earlier Study” [IMFAR May 2007]

    Balzola F et al . “Autistic enterocolitis: confirmation of a new inflammatory bowel disease in an Italian cohort of patients.” Gastroenterology 2005;128(Suppl. 2);A-303.

  3. drgoodhart says:

    Anonymous is correct: The FDA did not remove Thimerosal from the market. The Public Health Service (including the FDA, NIH, CDC and Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) (who I glibly referred to as “the great gods of government”) and the American Academy of Pediatrics issued two Joint Statements, in 1999 and 2000, urging vaccine manufacturers to reduce or eliminate Thimerosal in vaccines “as soon as possible.” Fluzone (Sanofi Pasteur, Inc.) still contains Thimerosal, but the other manufacturers of influenza vaccines appear to have removed Thimerosal or never had it. I didn’t want to get sidetracked into all the hellish details, but those interested in reading further can look here.

  4. seo says:

    Hello, great comment. I look forward to your next article. Thank you, Sammi

  5. UGG Boots says:

    I found this article useful in a paper I am writing at university. Hopefully, I get an A+ now!


    Bernice Franklin

  6. online payday loan canada says:

    I am bare impressed with the article I have just read. I wish the author of can continue to provide so much productive information and unforgettable experience to readers. There is not much to state except the following universal truth: Idle minds are a chance to think for yourself I will be back.

  7. Britt M. Borden says:

    Thank you for taking the time to talk about this, I feel fervently about it and I like learning about this topic. If possible, as you gain data, please add to this blog with more information. I have found it very useful.

  8. discount amazon says:

    great read. I would love to follow you on twitter.

  9. How to Get Rid of Hemorrhoids says:

    Just thought you’d be interested to know that I have added you to my bookmarks.

    I’ve seen your other blog posts as well and I think you’ve got great content. Keep it going!

  10. anti aging says:

    Hey Great post. Really a very nice piece of information. Newbies like me get a good idea about this… I’m going to comment now… I think i did it. Thank you..

  11. affiliate millionaire says:

    Just a quick comment to thank you 4 your interesting page article. Do u know where I could find more on the subject? x

  12. fraternity says:

    Enjoyed the posts..

  13. aloe products says:

    Great thread. Enjoyed the posts..

  14. forex robot says:

    What a great resource!

  15. Lenard Mangiapane says:

    This blog is great. How did you come up with the idea?

  16. drgoodhart says:

    There didn’t seem to be anyone blogging about these topics so I thought I would give it a whirl and see if anyone else would have similar interests. Because so much of my energy has gone into hyperbaric oxygen therapy, I believed I had something to add that other people might find useful.

  17. Fine Food says:

    thanks for that

  18. Enriqueta Kercado says:

    This is a great blog you got here. The theme looks nice, awesome color combination.

  19. Roderick Mcphie says:

    Hi – It’s good to find such topical stuff on the Internet as I have been able to discover here. I agree with most of what is written here and I’ll be returning to this site again. Thanks again for posting such great reading material!!

  20. Schedule says:

    Maybe you should change the blog subject title The autism blowup at The Lancet | Public Protection Lawyer's Blog to something more suited for your subject you create. I enjoyed the blog post withal.

  21. animal cuts review says:

    How’s things decent short article for The autism blowup at The Lancet

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s